Articles

This page presents my published research and publicly available preprints. Preprints represent work made publicly accessible prior to or during peer review and may differ from subsequent published versions. Links to journal publications, DOI records, and accessible versions are provided where available.

Published

Examining the Einstein-Bergson Controversy about Time Considering the Time-Energy Uncertainty Principle

Status: Published – Journal of Philosophical Investigations, Vol. 20, No. 54, pp. 377–394

This paper revisits the famous 1922 debate between Einstein and Bergson on the nature of time, outlining its central philosophical and scientific points of contention and re-evaluating them in light of developments in quantum physics. Einstein’s conception of time is that of an objective, measurable, and relative dimension within a static four-dimensional “block universe.” In contrast, Bergson conceives of time (durée) as a qualitative, continuous, and creative flow of consciousness that resists reduction to quantitative measurement. The emergence of quantum mechanics, particularly the Heisenberg time–energy uncertainty principle, introduces new complexities that challenge this dichotomy. Quantum features of time, such as intrinsic uncertainty, the indeterminacy of precise moments, and the relational role of the observer, undermine the deterministic framework of classical and relativistic physics and appear, at least superficially, to resonate with Bergson’s critique of spatialized, discrete conceptions of time. However, a closer examination reveals that quantum time remains a quantitative, physical construct distinct from Bergson’s qualitative durée. Drawing upon modern theories such as loop quantum gravity (as articulated by Carlo Rovelli and Lee Smolin) and the insights of contemporary philosophers, this study argues that neither a purely physical nor a purely philosophical approach can, in isolation, account for the multifaceted nature of time. Rather, a comprehensive understanding requires a synthesis of both, recognizing them as complementary perspectives on a single underlying reality.

View article on journal website → https://philosophy.tabrizu.ac.ir/article_20678.html

DOI → 10.22034/jpiut.2025.69665.4267

Preprint

What Grounds Dimension? Dynamical Accessibility and Ontological Commitment in Physics

Status: Preprint

Dimension is indispensable to modern physics, but formal indispensability does not establish ontological fundamentality. This paper asks what warrants the passage from representing physical phenomena within a dimensional structure to treating dimension as an independent and explanatorily prior feature of reality. It distinguishes mathematical description, physical realisation, and ontological fundamentality, arguing that evidence for dimension is invariably obtained through motion, propagation, scaling, interaction, and the number of dynamically accessible directions. A thought experiment involving a four-dimensional space of dynamical rank three shows that geometric independence and dynamical independence need not coincide. The argument is then developed through the inverse-square law, classical mechanics, general relativity, quantum field theory, string theory, effective low-dimensional systems, spectral dimension, and the Navier–Stokes equations. These cases reveal that dimensional labels acquire physical content through the organisation of processes rather than through an independent observation of dimension itself. The paper therefore proposes a positive criterion: dimensional attribution gains ontological weight only when its physical realisation is grounded in dynamically accessible structure and cannot be exhausted by representational usefulness. Dimension is not an established ontological ground of physics, but a presupposition whose justification remains outstanding.

View article on → https://www.researchsquare.com/article/rs-10833443/v1

DOI → https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-10833443/v1

A Wave Function of the Universe Is Not a Theory of the Universe: The Domain Problem and the Interface Architecture of Quantum Mechanics

Status: Preprint, Zenodo, 2026

Despite quantum mechanics’ unrivalled empirical success, its unrestricted formal applicability does not by itself establish that it provides a physically self-sufficient account of an entirely quantum world. This paper argues that the common operational core of quantum mechanics is not a complete theory of purely quantum reality. It is an interface architecture: it connects quantum states and transformations to physical preparations, measurement contexts, stable records, and definite outcomes. The argument distinguishes formal universality, conditional predictive adequacy, and physical self-sufficiency. Quantizing the apparatus extends the chain of quantum correlations but does not derive a single outcome from unitary dynamics; decoherence explains interference suppression, pointer stability, and record proliferation, but does not by itself convert an improper mixture into the actuality of one alternative. A closed universe provides the decisive test because preparation, subsystem decomposition, time, probability, and records can no longer be assigned to an external domain. Decoherent histories, Everettian quantum mechanics, Bohmian mechanics, objective-collapse theories, relational quantum mechanics, and contextual approaches are accordingly analysed as distinct strategies for closing or redefining the interface. The diagnosis extends to quantum field theory and quantum gravity: quantizing matter, apparatuses, reference frames, or geometry does not alone close the record interface. A fundamental theory must derive, constrain, or replace the conditions under which determinate empirical reality becomes possible. The measurement problem is therefore a local manifestation of a broader problem concerning the physical domain of quantum mechanics.

View article on → https://zenodo.org/records/22881130

DOI → https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22881130

Limiting Cases as Regime Architecture in Physics

Status: Preprint, Zenodo, 2026

Limiting cases are commonly treated either as mathematical operations on equations or as formal relations between successive theories. Neither treatment explains what makes a limit physically significant, how several operations cooperate in actual cases, or why limiting relations matter even when they do not establish reduction. This article develops a regime-architectural account. A limiting-case relation is physically licensed when an admissible class of parameter paths, a domain of application, mappings between relevant structures, mediating operations, an independently fixed recovery criterion, and two evidential stages form a connected constraint system. Its structure is represented as :  establishes that physical systems occupy the stated regime, whereas  independently tests the regime predictions generated by the preceding components. This separation blocks circular licensing. Universal constraints of path admissibility, prospective error control, evidential independence, and robustness give the framework exclusionary and normative force while leaving the physical content of each component case-specific. Effective field theory supplies a technically mature instantiation; categorical formalisms illuminate mappings and equivalence but do not replace physical parameter paths, domains, or evidence. Newton’s polygonal construction in Proposition I of the Principia provides a historical prototype. The Newtonian regimes of relativity and the quantum-classical transition exhibit regular and compound recovery, while phase transitions establish singular regime organization. Limiting cases thereby produce depth unification and epistemic compression: they specify which effective descriptions apply, how their domains are connected, and what would falsify the connection.

View article on → https://zenodo.org/records/22881727

DOI → https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22881727

Measurement Is Not Absolute: Metric Access Condition and Identifiability of Curvature

Status: Preprint, Zenodo, 2026

Gaussian curvature is intrinsic to a specified metric, but this mathematical invariance does not ensure that every physically possible measuring system can identify that metric. A ruler, clock, signal, or detector is itself a physical system; its records must be connected to a target geometry by a further account of its behavior. I formulate this distinction as an identifiability condition on the records available to a specified measurement architecture. A global example makes the condition concrete. A paraboloid has a complete induced metric with positive Gaussian curvature everywhere, while vertical projection supplies a second, globally flat metric on the same surface. A metrology restricted to the projected metric has exactly the same complete metric records on the paraboloid as it has on a plane. The example establishes a possible failure of access to the induced curvature; it does not claim that instruments produce either metric, that every physical probe is so restricted, or that a complete relativistic observer has been constructed. In metric general relativity, agreement among clocks, rods, light, and freely falling bodies provides strong evidence for a shared chronogeometric structure. That agreement rests on physical relations among those systems and the metric, rather than following from coordinate invariance alone. Curvature can thus be objectively and precisely measured under established coupling assumptions without measurement being absolute across all possible physical standards.

View article on → https://zenodo.org/records/23077146

DOI → https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23077146

Constitutive Closure and the Cost of Observable Attribution in Quantum Measurement

Status: Preprint, Zenodo, 2026

The spectral measure of a Hamiltonian and the POVM implemented by an apparatus need not coincide. We formulate observable attribution relative to an apparatus class defined by its preparations, controls, ancillary couplings, memory, and readable records. For a nondegenerate qutrit coupled to a binary threshold pointer and an amplifying environment, the explicit dynamics induces a classical observer channel that preserves only ground-versus-excited weight. We prove complete factorization of every allowed primitive through this channel and lift it to all finite adaptive protocols. Thus repetition, coherent controls within the excited sector, sector-only ancillas, calibration, and feed-forward cannot distinguish the two excited eigenstates. The full energy PVM is not attributable to the base class, and its optimal worst-case total-variation error is exactly one half. Adding a selective sector-changing control realizes the full PVM. Within the specified finite-protocol resource model, its exact minimum integrated operator-norm action is ; the optimal one-pulse approximate cost is also obtained in closed form. For imperfect devices we derive an exact minimax decoder for arbitrary calibrated binary responses, explicit error floors from record overlap, leakage, detuning, and dephasing, and a diamond-norm stability theorem for finite adaptive protocols. Observable attribution is therefore determined by physically available channels and resources, although the outcome statistics of every fixed experiment remain objective.

View article on → https://zenodo.org/records/22882567

DOI → https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22882567

Explanatory Adequacy in Relational Quantum Mechanics: From Relational Events to Relational Histories

Status: Preprint, Zenodo, 2026

This paper examines the explanatory adequacy of formulations of relational quantum mechanics by distinguishing two levels of relationality. Intra-event relationality concerns the specification of a fact that obtains relative to a system in a particular interaction; inter-event relationality concerns the constraints connecting an event to subsequent events, physical records, and a relational history. Using established results from measurement theory, we show that an effect can specify the statistics of the current outcome without uniquely determining the conditional operation or the statistics of subsequent sequences. Likewise, a fixed coupling and ready state do not uniquely determine the structure of retrievable records unless the readout is specified. We accordingly introduce a task-relative criterion of explanatory adequacy: the required structures must be assessed against the particular explanatory role that a formulation assigns to an event, a relational fact, or a link between perspectives. The conclusion is not that RQM must derive instruments, dynamics, or linking rules from relational principles. A formulation that explicitly incorporates these structures can be fully adequate for the task in question. The paper contributes a distinction between intra-event and inter-event adequacy, a unified criterion for the division of explanatory labor, and a task-relative definition of an architectural deficit.

View article on → https://zenodo.org/records/23082085

DOI → https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23082085

Two Explanatory Functions of Time in Physical Theories: A Functional Analysis from Classical Mechanics to Relativity and Quantum Theory

Status: Preprint, Zenodo, 2026

Physics uses temporal concepts to formulate evolution, order events, and compare processes, but “time” does not perform one function across theories. This article identifies two recurrent explanatory functions in classical mechanics, relativity, and quantum theory. The representational and ordering function parametrizes states, events, and histories; the process-based and timekeeping function ties temporal quantities to specified paths, changes, clocks, events, or protocols. These are context-dependent roles, not two substances or fixed classes of quantities: proper time, for instance, describes a worldline’s duration and can also parametrize its evolution. Four diagnostic indicators reconstruct a quantity’s predominant role. Case studies show how the functions overlap without making their mathematically distinct realizations equivalent. The distinction clarifies why clocks mediate between processes and representational scales, why the absence of a universal time operator does not exclude measurable temporal quantities, and why time–energy relations do not express a single uncertainty of “time.” It also constrains inference: a conclusion established for one temporal role cannot be transferred to the other without independent argument. Claims about the elimination, fundamentality, or emergence of time must therefore identify the function and theoretical level at issue. The framework reveals continuity in the architecture of temporal explanation while preserving the differences among physical theories.

View article on → https://zenodo.org/records/23156957

DOI → https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23156957

When Is Ontological Suspension Legitimate? Newtonian Restraint and Quantum Understanding

Status: Preprint, Zenodo, 2026

Quantum mechanics is often presented through a forced choice: either a physical theory becomes intelligible only after it specifies what reality is intrinsically, or predictive and operational success is all the understanding physics can legitimately seek. This article rejects that choice. Newton’s treatment of gravitation shows how a theory may provide substantial physical understanding by identifying mathematically articulated dependencies, unifying phenomena, and supporting counterfactual reasoning while leaving the underlying mechanism unsettled. Yet Newtonian restraint was not a prohibition on why-questions. It was a rule for withholding answers that could not be inferred from the phenomena while keeping causal inquiry open. On this basis, the article develops a criterion of calibrated ontological suspension. Suspension is legitimate, relative to a specified explanatory task, when the theory supplies adequate dependency structure, rival ontologies remain evidentially underdetermined, the unanswered ontological question is not constitutive of the explanandum, and the suspension remains revisable. It becomes illegitimate when the missing commitment changes what counts as an outcome, a mechanism, a domain of application, or a solution to the problem posed. Applied to quantum mechanics, the criterion yields a differentiated verdict. Interference, probabilistic constraints, symmetries, and no-go theorems afford genuine structural understanding without a complete intrinsic picture; indeed, no-go results sharply restrict admissible ontologies. By contrast, in the measurement problem, determinate outcomes are part of the explanandum, so their status cannot simply be bracketed. Decoherence explains stability and suppression of interference but does not by itself select a single outcome. The proposal is therefore neither a new Copenhagen interpretation nor an instrumentalist dismissal of ontology. It is a methodological account of when ontological incompleteness is compatible with, and when it obstructs, physical understanding.

View article on → https://zenodo.org/records/23290645

DOI → https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23290645

Dynamical Architecture and the Physical Organization of Evolution

Status: Preprint, Zenodo, 2026

Interaction specifications acquire determinate evolutionary effects through a system’s lawful response organization. This article distinguishes kinematical structure, response rules, interaction contributions, and selected problem data. Newtonian inertia and free quantum spreading identify physical response properties that the specified electric or potential coupling does not determine. Hydrogen supplies a complementary contrast: the classical Coulomb Hamiltonian is globally unbounded below, although it admits bound orbits, whereas the quantum Coulomb Hamiltonian has a lower energy bound and a stationary ground-state distribution. Integration connects these cases: the organization that sustains free evolution also determines the joint effects of several contributions on one system. These results establish explanatory priority for response organization in determining how specified interactions affect histories. A realist argument establishes the ontological status of the represented response properties and their independence from the specified coupling. Their microscopic origin is a separate explanatory question. Structural causal relevance is demonstrated by physically different inertial responses under a common law and fixed electric coupling. A further application separates time-reversal symmetry, closure of admitted histories, and invertibility of retained-state maps. Restricted Gaussian preparations, outgoing waves, and a nonselective measurement distinguish these questions and locate the relevant restrictions and information loss within complete physical problems. The article’s central result is the connection between free evolution, integrated response, and the independent physical status of response organization.

View article on → https://zenodo.org/records/23292224

DOI → https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23292224

Explaining Physical Coupling: Reciprocal Closure and the Limits of Response Reconstruction

Status: Preprint, Zenodo, 2026

A physical model may reproduce the observable behavior of an interaction without explaining the physical organization that realizes it or the origin of its characteristics. This raises a question about the scope and adequacy of physical explanation: what does successful response reconstruction explain about an interaction, and what remains unexplained? This article develops a framework for assessing the explanatory content of interaction models by distinguishing three achievements: recovering the response, identifying the physical organization that realizes it, and explaining the origin of the channel’s characteristics from independent premises. An ‘interaction profile’ specifies the features to be explained, while ‘reciprocal closure’ assesses the consistency of mutual dependencies and backreaction within a shared dynamical problem. The methodological contribution connects a criterion for response recovery with an assessment of the origin of interaction characteristics. Examples from several physical systems show that preserving the response alone neither uniquely identifies the realizing organization nor explains the origin of the channel’s coefficients and features. Applying the framework to entropic gravity, we distinguish the premises responsible for the form of the force law, interaction strength, and universality of acceleration. In particular, additivity of mass and entropy change alone does not ensure a common ratio of entropy sensitivity to inertial mass. The analysis provides a way to identify an explanation’s achievements, isolate its remaining independent assumptions, and specify conditions for progress in explaining the origin of physical interactions.

View article on → https://zenodo.org/records/23636790

DOI → https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23636790

What Do Fundamental Statements Do? Functional Roles and Ontological Determination in Physical Theories

Status: Preprint, Zenodo, 2026

Labels such as law, principle, postulate, and axiom group statements that perform different tasks in physical theories. This article argues that a component’s inferential warrant depends on its role within a specified theoretical architecture, not on its label. It distinguishes six functional roles and operationalizes them by three diagnostic tests. It then separates formal structure, empirical connection, and physical ontology, and analyzes ontological determination along four dimensions. Comparisons among classical mechanics, relativity, and quantum mechanics, followed by audits of complementarity and the measurement problem, show that formal precision and empirical success constrain ontology without selecting a unique realization.

View article on → https://zenodo.org/records/23470646

DOI → https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23470646

The Uneven Death of the Ether: Functional Unbundling and the Fate of a Scientific Object

Status: Preprint, Zenodo, 2026

The ether did not disappear from physics in a single experimental or conceptual event. It had carried a bundle of tasks: filling space, securing contact action, supporting waves, defining rest, storing energy and momentum, and giving physical structure to space. This article reconstructs the ether’s decline by tracking those tasks rather than treating the ether as one enduring object. It applies a need-bearer-function-fate matrix from plenism and wave optics through Maxwell, Lorentz, Einstein, quantum vacuum discourse, and Einstein-aether theory. The reconstruction shows three distinct outcomes: elimination of a function, transfer of a function to fields or spacetime geometry, and persistence of an explanatory need under a new formulation. This functional continuity neither identifies modern fields with historical ethers nor establishes a realist lineage. It explains instead why the ether could die unevenly: its mechanical carrier and privileged frame were rejected while several of its former jobs survived elsewhere.

View article on → https://zenodo.org/records/23417068

DOI → https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23417068